Government & Regulatory | Top Story
EIA’s “Glut” Calls: The 2025 Surplus Claim — and How 2021–2024 Forecasts Actually Held Up
Print
|
The “~2.2 MMb/d glut in 2025” framing traces to the EIA’s Short-Term Energy Outlook (STEO), December 2025. EIA doesn’t usually write “glut” in the tables—what they publish is the implied balance via inventories: “world total crude oil and other liquids inventory net withdrawals.” A negative number means inventory builds (supply > demand). In the December 2025 STEO, the 2025 world total is –2.24 MMb/d, which is where the “~2.2” number comes from.
But the better question is the one you’re asking: do these big balance calls hold up when you look back? So below is a clean “forecast vs. reality” check for 2021–2024.
How the back-test works
-
Forecast = what EIA said in the January STEO for that year (their “start-of-year” view)
-
Actual = what EIA later carried as history in the December 2025 STEO dataset
Metric = World petroleum and other liquids supply and consumption, in MMb/d
What this says in plain English:
-
EIA was directionally correct in 2021–2023 (draw, then builds).
-
2024 is the key exception: EIA started the year calling for a slight draw, but the year finished as a noticeable build.
The conclusions you can actually use
1) “Big surplus” headlines are not the main problem — direction flips are
The main credibility hit isn’t a 0.2–0.3 MMb/d magnitude miss. It’s when the call changes sign.
That’s exactly what happened in 2024: EIA began the year calling a slightly tighter market, but it ended as a looser market. That’s the kind of miss that can mislead decision-makers (hedging, capital pacing, inventory strategy).
2) EIA’s forecasts tend to be “smooth” — reality is lumpy
2021 shows the classic pattern: EIA called a draw, but underestimated how tight it would be. When markets are moving through regime shifts (post-COVID recovery, sanctions, OPEC+ discipline), EIA often understates volatility.
3) 2023 is the “best case” example of EIA usefulness
In 2023, EIA’s balance was nearly spot-on even though supply and demand both surprised higher. That’s a reminder: EIA can be very useful when the system is stable and the misses cancel.
4) What this implies for the “2.2 MMb/d glut” in 2025
A projected –2.24 MMb/d build rate is huge—but your back-test shows the right mental model:
-
Treat it as a risk flag (market could be looser), not a certainty.
-
The error bands are large enough that if supply under-delivers or demand over-delivers by ~1 MMb/d, the “glut” narrative can shrink fast.
More Government & Regulatory News
Dallas Fed Energy Survey: What Oil and Gas Executives Are Really Saying
The latest Dallas Fed Energy Survey shows a U.S. oil and gas industry that is not collapsing—but is clearly constrained. Executives are operating in a defensive posture, focused…
MEG Energy Rejects Strathcona Resources' $6 Billion Takeover Offer
MEG Energy Rejects Strathcona Resources' $6 Billion Takeover Offer Overview of the Offer: Bidder: Strathcona Resources Ltd. Offer: 0.62 Strathcona shares + $4.10 in cash per MEG share…
PDC Energy Second Quarter 2022 Results
PDC Energy, Inc. announced its 2022 second quarter financial and operating results, and provided second half 2022 guidance. The company also announced receiving Completeness Determination on the Guanella…
PDC Energy's 69-Well Kenosha Project Approved by COGCC
PDC Energy Inc. reported that the Colorado Oil and Gas Conservation Commission (COGCC) approved the Company's Kenosha Oil & Gas Development Plan (OGDP) permit application. The Kenosha OGDP,…
Biden to Release One Million BPD from Reserves for Six Months; Push for Federal Leasehold Production
The White House and President Joe Biden have announced that they will be releasing one million barrels per day from the US' Strategic Petroleum Reserves in order to…
Canada News
Western Canada Upstream M&A: Q1 2026 Transaction Report
Western Canadian M&A activity in Q1 2026 was characterized by a 87% decrease in total deal value compared to Q1 2025, totaling $0.8 billion C$. However, transaction volume…
A Quiet Capital Pattern Is Forming in North American Upstream — and Almost No One Is Talking About It
A handful of recent transactions and capital raises point to a subtle pattern in North American upstream—one that is easy to miss because each event, on its own,…
Canadan E&P 2026 Program Calls for 448 Net Wells, Up 24% vs. 2025 Plan
Canadian Natural Resources outlined a 2026 operating capital budget of approximately $6.3 billion (total capital budget $6,425 million, including $125 million for carbon capture) targeting 1,590–1,650 MBOE/d of…
Whitecap Details 2026 Duvernay & Montney Program
Whitecap Resources reported strong third quarter 2025 operating and financial results, marking its first full quarter following the strategic combination with Veren that closed on May 12, 2025.…
ARC Resources: Lower 2026 Capex, Higher Volumes
ARC Resources used its third quarter update to reinforce a familiar message to Canadian E&P executives: disciplined capital, structurally better market access, and a growing shareholder return program…
United States News
Baytex 2026 Development Plans
Baytex’s 2026 development plan reflects a post–Eagle Ford sale capital program and a sharpened focus on its core Canadian assets. The Company approved 2026 exploration and development expenditures…
Tourmaline: 2026 Capital Program Locked In at $2.9B
Tourmaline’s 2026 exploration and production (EP) program is set at $2.9 billion and targets average production of 690,000–710,000 boepd, with the company maintaining the multi-year EP Plan released…
Cenovus Outlines 2026 Development Plan Following MEG Integration
Cenovus’ 2026 plan targets capital investment of $5.0 billion to $5.3 billion (including ~$350 million of capitalized turnaround costs) and upstream production of 945,000 BOE/d to 985,000 BOE/d,…
Gran Tierra Energy To Step Down Activity in 2026
Gran Tierra Energy’s 2026 development plan reflects a step-down in spending and activity as the company transitions from fulfilling Ecuador exploration commitments in 2025 toward a free-cash-flow-focused program.…
Advantage Plans $300–$330MM 2026 Capital Program
Advantage’s 2026 development plan centers on Glacier-focused drilling and key midstream work. The company plans total capital spending of $300 million to $330 million and expects production to…